Friday, September 19, 2008

Hindu Rituals- An Economic balancing Act- turning sour

Well! Call me an atheist for the views expressed, least bothered!

 

What is economic balancing?

 

Isn’t Economic Balancing is an act of channelizing certain money flow from the rich to poor? This was never better done than that was followed in the Hindu Rituals. As an example, the daily rituals- bathing idols with various liquids including water, scent, yoghurt, ghee, honey, mixture of fruits, tender coconut, decorating with flowers. Those who needs something-unfulfilled, those who has sorrow, those who has committed sin and want to lessen the burden, does these rituals. They donate money for performing these rituals in various temples. Who are those people with unfulfilled desire, those with full of sorrow, those with disease, and those who have committed sin? Though not everybody, but mostly those who are well to do have these attributes in common. Those who have money have unfulfilled desire, since unfulfilled, their heart is full of sorrow and some money is always earned by doing some or other sin (maybe a minor or major) and it’s needless to say disease is an uninvited guest with being rich.

 

By practicing these rituals, they keep their faith on “God” and because of doing these rituals they believe that the “God” would be pleased. And this “God” would, as a return of favour of accepting these rituals, would fulfill whatever they have asked for. Does it sound funny? I would rather say, whosoever has recommended these thousands of years before is a real intelligent and have philanthropic attitude.

If you would carefully watch the things that are used for these rituals are those that are manufactured or traded by small time business people or poor people for their daily life and earnings. These things would not cost a heaven. And last but not least, these rituals are done daily (by someone or other). Those who are well to do purchase these commodities there by the sales is ensured for the daily business people. These things are offered to “God” and distributed as a token of God’s gift to all people in the vicinity. By this the poor business people gets business done, poor people who do not even have food are served with food. A nutritious one with fruits, honey, milk, yoghurt, rice etc.

 

Does “God” fulfill the needs by performing these rituals? Yes and No. God is highly rational. God never gives anything to anybody nor takes anything from anybody. There is no discrimination (but now don’t ask then why there is a poor and rich).So God is not human to be “pleased” by the rituals and “return the favour”. So he doesn’t fulfill the needs because of rituals. By putting God within quotes, I emphasize the misunderstanding people generally have. God is God and not “God”. But, by keeping faith on “God”, those who perform these rituals pass the burden to some arbitrary and start concentrate on whatever they have to do. And because of the faith and because of channelized concentration, they get their desire fulfilled. But a new desire is also created with that, that’s nature-isn’t it?

 

But why to pass the buck on a ritual? Isn’t it falsehood? Does Hinduism preach false hope? No! Hinduism knows the mentality of human being. Human beings are so selfish to part with their money. Unless some benefit is created, even you and me, wouldn’t spend the money-would we? An arbitrary benefit is created and thus the money is circulated.

 

Now don’t you agree whosoever have formulated those rituals are genius? Aren’t they a real Economist?

 

But is this globally applicable? How long would this technique be valid? I bet, yes wherever human beings are there, until human beings don’t despise free lunch, until human beings are becoming selfless, this technique would hold good. It’s eternal!

 

If so why am I worried? Is it not all for good? Yes it is all for good. But at some corner of my heart, I do see some wastage. My village is about 20,000 families. It houses some 50-60 temples of various deities. Small and big, old and new -all mixed. I happen to know small information that on a day to day basis some 10 lts of milk is being given for bathing the idols per large/old (“powerful”) temple. And there would be5-6 such temple in each of the village. On an average a temple would be getting 300 lts of milk. Added to that not less than 200-300 lts of milk is used for special days and these special days comes at least two to three times a month. So for a month, considering the minimum, a temple gets around 500 lts of milk. Sad part is all this milk goes to drainage and is not consumed by poor people. At the best, the priest steals it. In either case, the purpose of creating the ritual is lost-not the ritual-I meant the “real purpose” This is the case of one temple. So the considering remaining temples, large temple would consume 3000 lts and other temples would consume 20-30% of large temple averaging to another 1000 lts. A village of 20,000 people wastes 4000 lts of milk per month. Just convert that for the whole state and then to whole country? Doesn’t the figure is sounds too alarming?

6 comments:

  1. Hi
    I do agree with you on the extreme thing/actions people would take/do in the name of God/religion ...how far will one goes to prove to God his/her piety and devotion that no amount of money can buy (by spending money on objectivity that one thinks valuable to God). Instead seeing that having God (to me) is a w/in thing...which, through humanity acts, we serve and seek a better side w/in us (the Godly (truth) human within..the one that will not doubt his daily action is just on all counts)..i am not a religious person, but i do not against the religious view and practice of others. God will always come into perspective when one is doubtful, that i am very sure. The thing is yes we can do our prays as a mean to give us psychological peace..but if we do want to reach God (the one that live w/in us all along)we need to make social service our calling. Not just washing our money blindly down the drain in God's name...i think God would be happier if we reach out to others in need in the name of God, because it is how God's name will live on..hope all religious people would understand this point...
    Also, for you alone...please change your setting on Orkut so everyones can scrap you...you may not want people to read your scrap book or see your pics...but allow people other than friends can scrap you will allow me too to respond to your query...ty
    Kim

    ReplyDelete
  2. hi karthi
    what u hav said is a age old blunder happening irrespective of religious faith but there are temples in which d mgmt does certain amt of justice .....not entirely as u hav said still v hav temples which feed the poor nd the diseased @ sm plzces n chennai do that especially in as far as i know "madhya kailash".....
    nd jus 1 more thing
    u said abt ur village ...... its quite tough to argue with superstitious faith but u can try nd encourage ppl to feed the poor by anna dhanam nd all ....if u ppl start it ...then there can b sm change brought in ur plce rite
    coz those rich ppl who pray to wash away there sin cant stop sinning nd ofcourse they ll cm to "god" again nd again if they dont care abt spendin make them spend on anna dhan by promoting it ....than telling not to follow the blind faith ....then the ancient purpose ll be revived ....


    btw u still in orkut..

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi,

    Kim.. thanks for the post.. and yep, i have changed my orkut settings..

    Btw, I still dont understand why should be God be happy / sad about anything. If God is subject to happiness and sad, are we not bringing God to Human form? God is indifferent to all, anything, emotionless... God is God. We get a positive energy by doing social services and that positive energy brings happiness...

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi meera,

    You are 100% right its tough to argue religious faith. Leave alone my village, i cannot even change the thinking in my family.

    As koundamani says in one of his joke.. " இந்த உலகத்த நம்பலால மாத்த முடியாது, நான் மாறிக்கிறேன்" I cant change the attitude of this world, least , i change myself.

    Annadhanam is quiet a good way of philanthropy but by and large it is misused. As Robert Ludlum says via one of the character Andrea Bancroft in the novel Bancroft Strategy, "And there is a question of Downstream Consequences, perverse effects.. finally the scheme shouldn't be like the pediatrician who saved life of little Adolf Hitler". Annadhanam helps 90% of people and also instigates 10% of lazyness in people. but nothing in this world can be perfect.. so 90% needs to be concentrated rather than 10%....

    BTW, i am in orkut..Search for "KGN" or http://www.orkut.com/Profile.aspx?uid=1943917068468127338

    ReplyDelete
  5. hi karthi .... two days back it was mahalaya ammavasai ....i nd i had the same rage over the all of a sudden god fearin ppl ....
    i actually went to mylapore kabalishwarar kovil .....the street was tooo clumsy ppl dont even care abt how much they litter ...then ppl cm for begging ...u know very young perfectly fit ppl were there
    ....
    then as if these r not enough
    while ppl beg outside d temple
    hundreds of so called devotees they did their tharpanams nd so much of food nd stuuf got dumped in the pool
    aft that ppl ofcourse threw the carry bags also in the so called sacred poool....
    apart from this i dont understand how cm ppl do the rituals without evn knowing the meaning of wat they do ...coz many of them found it a funny process aft doin but b4 that it was sacred one .....
    im sry but i cant help feelin furious with all these clumsy business ..... i do like temple but this much of a idiotism nd mess is quite horible ...

    nd then i thought of this blog nd felt like spilling out wat i felt ....
    wat d u say for this karthi even u do these thidhi nd all nah

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hi Meera,

    First, i don't do 'thidhi' coz both my parents are alive.

    Mahalaya Ammavasai is almost performed by many religion in the world. Surprisingly, you will find that for the no-moon day falling this month, Chinese, japanese, Indonesians, Filipinos, Koreans pay tribute to their earlier generation who are no more.

    Muslims pay tribute to past generation during Ramzan and the third day from Mahalaya ammavasai is Eid for them. I am not recollecting the Christian one...though...

    However, i do not approve spoiling the environment for this sake. My father does this thithi in home itself.

    Kapaleeswar temple is one of my fav temple. I just love it. I feel sad when you describe the nasty way how they have spoiled the place...

    As i said while replying to your earlier comment, the downside of charity is developing these kind of sociopath...

    ReplyDelete